“A communist takes your money for the benefit of the totalitarian state. A socialist takes your money for the benefit of the nanny state. A Wall Street capitalist takes your money for his own benefit but claims it’ll be for your own good—after he’s invested the money on your behalf in God knows what. A common thief is someone who takes your money without any phony-baloney pretensions at all.”
—Economic Philosophy for the Non-economist, Chapter 3 [written after the Great Recession]
There is, of course, a profoundly troubling fact to which we must resign ourselves. Our elected leaders have no intention of ever being fiscally responsible: living within our means, making hard choices, spending money wisely, paying off existing debt, funding unfunded liabilities, saving for the future.
None whatsoever.
It’s our own fault. We won’t elect them otherwise, and they know this.
There is no difference between Democrats or Republicans in this regard.
None. Whatsoever.
Borrowing and printing money allow them to increase spending and decrease taxes—deferring the financial consequences to the future. Our going deep into hock and devaluing our currency has gotten them our votes.
It is in the future that we will at long last behave responsibly, future politicians and future voters alike.
“We promise!” a voice from the future yells to us.
Except that we’re all a bunch of fucking liars and will do no such damn thing.
Sure, an argument could be made that the basic economic philosophies between the two political parties are different, if not always implemented. Republicans borrow and spend—and defer inevitable huge tax increases to a later date. Democrats borrow and spend and tax more now—and defer the rest of the tax increases to the future. But this distinction is merely one of the means of economic suicide—jumping off a skyscraper vs. blowing one’s brains out. Both paths lead to a common destination: an increasingly unbalanced accounting ledger which is ultimately our nation’s financial ruin.
Do not delude yourself into believing either of the major political parties is more fiscally responsible than the other—or that we can avoid a tragic end. Throughout history, fiscal imprudence has brought ruin to empires and kingdoms as surely as an invading horde ever could.
Admirably, the barbarian harbors no silly excuses; he means to rape, pillage, and burn. Conversely, the Lords of Finance lay waste to our towns and fields and violate our womenfolk because they know better than the peasants how to borrow, lend, and put capital to its most productive use. In this regard, the Wall Street fat cat is remarkably similar to his communist counterpart, the central planner. Self-assuredly they march us toward a common abyss; at the point of either a bayonet or a financial derivative.
Unfortunately, no modern version of the Teutonic Knights will ride to defend us. Shed yourself of denial and any foolhardy faith that no matter what happens, the government will make things financially right in the end. Government is a willing ally of these privileged Huns, complicit in opening up for conquest new, unspoiled, drowsy lands where the peasants have grown fat and complacent. Financial disaster is to where we are inexorably headed. Any fool can see this. Every fool ignores it.
On occasion, politicians from either major party crow about their good intentions to change their profligate ways—much like an alcoholic swears to his sobbing wife that he’ll finally stop beating her and go to that Alcoholics Anonymous meeting. Except that the politician never goes to that meeting, never stands up on that first night and announces to the group: “My name is (Senator or Congressman or Governor or State Assemblyman so-and-so), and I’m a fiscally irresponsible borrow-aholic.”
The fact is we voters don’t want our elected official to go to that AA meeting and change his fiscally foolish ways unless it’s someone else’s wife being beaten. I know this last sentence sounds strange, but read it a few more times, and you’ll see what I mean.
I’ll share with you a quote from a newspaper article written during the troubled economic times of 2007-2009, which was, in fact, the inspiration for this book:
“Investors are not convinced that the measures governments are taking will be sufficient.”
So was cited Darrell Duffie, Stanford University economics professor, in the San Francisco Chronicle, October 11, 2008. The government bailouts weren’t big enough to his liking.
When I first read this statement, I angrily bolted up in my chair.
Sufficient!
Good God, the ham-handed economic stimulus “measures” implemented are the financial equivalent of aiming a fire hose at a drowning man! The term economic stimulus—and the imperative need for a sufficient amount of it—passed the lips of politicians and economists and pundits alike, seemingly with each breath exhaled from their lying mouths, and which meant borrowing (or printing) and spending more money (e.g., more debt, more currency debasement, more moral hazard); this despite the fact that for years and years we’d been economically stimulating our economy to death as clearly evident by corporate debt, federal deficit and debt, trade deficit, other government borrowing (e.g., state and municipal bonds and unfunded liabilities), as well as monstrous amounts of personal borrowing and spending.
The so-called richest country in history is by far its largest debtor.
Lack of economic stimulation was not the problem, any more than insufficient numbers of cancer cells is the problem with, well, cancer.
Lord, have mercy…additional debt is called for when too much debt is the goddamn problem? Amazingly stupid. It was as if the permissible level of arsenic in drinking water was increased from a few parts per million allowed to a million parts per million now required—and the element at high concentrations was found to be not toxic but an essential life-sustaining nutrient to which the human body must be heavily dosed for any hope of survival.
Here’s the context of Professor Duffie’s scholarly bon mot. His statement was in response to a large decline in worldwide stock markets which occurred despite weeks of economic meddling by the United States and many foreign governments, all of which was done to thaw out what was being called at the time a “credit freeze” or “credit crunch.” (Other terms bandied about ad nauseum by politicians and pundits were the terms bailout or its Orwellian newspeak cousins, Messieurs Rescue and Recovery).
This credit freeze supposedly imperiled the world’s economy. By credit freeze they meant an inability or difficulty for Wall Street, large corporations, and individuals to borrow money—mostly the first two of this trio. The rest of us (individuals) were a later addition to the mix in an attempt to make the bailout politically palatable (a rescue of Wall Street and Main Street).
Not surprisingly, the politicians and pundits who cawed on and on about quickly needed bailout proposals did a poor job of hiding the snide inference that the average voter was too dumb and unsophisticated to understand what was going on with the world’s economy—and certainly the cure was beyond our understanding as well. All we needed to know was that the bailout was really being done to save us. Shut up, ask no questions, demand no accountability, immediately hand over the money, and your betters will take care of everything.
Thanks, betters. For nothing—except a shitload more debt, a further debased currency, and an inevitable future economic fiasco that’s going to make this 2007-2009 debacle look like a quaint tea party.
Time magazine’s “Committee to Save the World” cover of February 15, 1999 was an ominous harbinger of what happened less than a decade later: The three clowns pictured, Fed Chair Alan Greenspan, Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin, and Deputy Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, who were anointed as heroes who would “save” the world from the bursting of the then Dot.com Bubble, were key perpetrators in the madness which led to the Great Recession of 2007-2009. Worse yet, these maestros of financial destruction established the template for dealing with all future financial crises: Do the same shit which caused the crisis, but on a far grander scale and which shall make future crises inevitable and far worse.
But that was then and this is now. We need the bailout this instant or all is lost!
See what I mean?
Ah, The Bailout. A much more extensive economic interference done on our behalf by the same idiots whose negligence and malfeasance (and interference) caused the bizarre situation in the first place.
Oh, eyes likes it! Sounds good to me, Massah. Keeps it up!
One problem.
It was bullshit, every last nanogram of it.
The only reason we heard caterwauling about the need for a bailout was because Wall Street fat cats got themselves into a royal jam, overextending themselves to a breathtaking extent. Had it only been individuals or small businesses who’d suffered the consequences of their own financial folly, these same fat cat recipients of corporate welfare would have preached the virtues of free-market capitalism and creative destruction and the need to suffer the consequences of one’s profligacy. I imagine the advice given to the masses (that’d be us) would’ve been, “You need to learn an important economics lesson, and harshness is a masterful teacher.”
Except that a credit freeze was not the real issue—it was merely a symptom of the fatal condition afflicting economies throughout the world: excessive credit (aka debt) for which the only hope of repayment is printing money (which will result in ruinous hyper-inflation) or ruinous huge tax increases (which will confiscate wealth and end equally terribly). Not to mention, the fact that much of the borrowed money went to non-productive uses (e.g., Wall Street gambling and their obscene bonuses, worthless college degrees, crappily built houses) rather than investments generating actual tangible wealth.
There’s another way to think about what happened: Robert Mugabe Economics. Mr. Mugabe, the despotic president of Zimbabwe, who printed money like crazy and confiscated wealth to the utter destruction of his country’s economy, might as well have been in charge of the United States economy in 2007-2009, as well as his own.
Why did so many governments and businesses and individuals go deep into hock, far beyond their means? Why was this encouraged by lenders and politicians—and not protested by voters or regulators? Why was onerous personal debt considered a realistic path to allow a person of inadequate means to purchase a well-furnished, upgraded-to-the-hilt McMansion rather than seen for what it truly was, a choice leading to the poor house? Why the orgy of borrowing and lending?
The flippant answer is because they could. No adults were around to stop the madness.
A slightly more thoughtful explanation lies in a perverse sense of entitlement which was its own disease replete with pernicious characteristic symptoms…owning a home is always preferable to renting; interest rates must be kept artificially low; loans must be made to people who cannot repay them for the purpose of buying homes they cannot afford; consumers must spend money rather than save; housing and stock prices must climb forever artificially higher—at least double digit increases each year; retirement accounts and pension funds must always increase in value irrespective of the underlying worth of the companies or other assets in which investments have been made; no person must be called upon to exhibit restraint or personal sacrifice or delay any sort of materialistic gratification; debts will be repaid by someone else, if not now, then in the future; wealth can be created by financial legerdemain rather than hard work, thrift, and real increases in productivity (i.e., foolishly believing phantom equity is real).
And the worst entitlement of all—that incompetence and recklessness if done on a huge enough scale, cannot result in the consequences inherent of true free-market capitalism, i.e., failure and bankruptcy and foreclosure. The Too Big to Fail Fallacy. If the company was too large or the number of irresponsible homebuyers too numerous, then something had to be done…
All this was a birthright, by gosh. We were entitled to every bit of it—free of untoward consequences. A crisis if we were denied any of it.
But it isn’t a right. No matter how much we wish otherwise.
Excessive borrowing (too much credit) is what caused the mess. Interest rates were lowered and lending standards were thrown out the window (like a too-vocal critic of Vladimir Putin). Loans were made to people (and businesses) who should not have been lent money, eagerly assisted by unscrupulous or negligent realtors and mortgage brokers and underwriters and appraisers, to buy stuff they couldn’t afford—hell, in many cases people were buying stuff they couldn’t afford even if the interest rate was zero!
After the loans were made, these were bought (with borrowed money) by highly-leveraged Wall Street firms and bundled together as mortgaged-backed “investments” which were then falsely assigned quality standards by credit rating companies who assured investors the bundled loans were sound. Next the packaged investments were guaranteed (the now infamous credit default swaps) by insurers who had no hope of ever paying out claims should these securities tank—and who insisted like fuck they not be regulated as insurance companies. This overly-perfumed, falsely-insured garbage was then sold all over the world to investors, unwitting and otherwise. At each step in the process government regulators drowsed impotently, deluding themselves that events could never turn out as they most certainly and obviously were destined to indeed come to pass.
And while the mighty bubble inflated and times were good, the financial media pundits, almost to a man (and woman), acting with no more acumen on economics than football cheerleaders would’ve acted on, well, economics, droned on and on about how two plus two equals a number much greater than four and would ever and always equal this fantasy number. Their highbrow mathematics assured them it would never equal four. To equal less than four was unfathomable.
Oh, it was damn well fathomable. It was as predictable as it was preventable.
The temptation is to blame capitalism for this sad state of affairs, and many folks did, but this is framing an innocent schmuck for murder. The economic behavior which led to these untoward events—and the subsequent bailouts—was socialism, not capitalism.
Yes, you heard correctly. Capitalism was not the cause of the problem.
This was not capitalism run amok for the simple reason it was not capitalism; it was not capitalism for a number of reasons, not the least of which is the politicians could not bring themselves to allow free-market consequences such as foreclosure, bankruptcy, and investment losses, which are to economic folly what Hell is to corporeal sin. In other words, the shit that keeps us in line. (Note: Poor schmucks were foreclosed on, but our betters ended up ultimately benefiting greatly from this.)
This is no surprise. We’ve been faux capitalists for quite some time. Continuously running federal deficits (including unfunded liabilities such as politically self-serving promises of future Social Security and Medicare spending for which a means of payment does not exist) is nothing more than denial of who we truly are: socialist pigs.
A true free-market economy requires spending decisions based on weighing cost versus benefit—and suffering consequences if the wrong decision is made. Deficit spending abrogates fiscal sobriety (at least for the present) and allows socialistic levels of government spending at capitalistic levels of revenue collection. Deficit spending is socialism masquerading as capitalism—or better yet…someday-we-will-be-capitalists.
Really we will.
Riiiiiight.
At this point, I must insist capitalism does not mean we get to do whatever the hell we want. Capitalism is not anarchy any more than socialism is a sincere concern about one’s fellow human beings. A free-market economy requires a good framework of rules—and an honest enforcement of these. Capitalism does not mean there should be no rules or regulations, but it does mean the rules should apply fairly to everyone, including requirements for transparency and honest accounting practices—and prudent lending and borrowing. If rules are not applied fairly, the “favored” economic behaviors result in economic inefficiencies at best, catastrophic bubbles at worst.
Most importantly, capitalism requires consequences, not bailouts. Otherwise, we set ourselves up for deferred catastrophes of increasingly larger magnitude. Hence, Dot.com Bubble begets Great Recession.
Bubbles eventually pop. That’s what they do. Bubbles are always large; otherwise, we’d not hear the pop. The housing bubble was leviathan in size. The popping of the subsequent bailout bubble—which we deliberately inflated and ignored—is going to be a real whopper. Any so-called recovery is destined to be fragile and illusory because it’s built on a foundation of ruinous debt and continued accounting gimmickry implemented by a people and its leaders who are weak and whiny.
Alas, if only we were actually capitalists.
Capitalism in the private sector means investments and resources find their best use based on “natural” free-market demand rather than central planning by government apparatchiks. This key tenet of capitalism does not result in a perfect economy or an idyllic world, but when compared to other economic systems it does result in incredible technological advancements and the most wealth creation and usually a reasonable distribution of these riches.
That’s the theory, anyway.
Fact turned out quite differently…for example, rather than as the result of unfettered free-market influences, houses were built, bought, mortgaged, and sold based on unnatural influences. People obtained riches for doing nothing more than temporarily squatting on a piece of property with no more actual wealth creation than that obtained by a gambler who happens to draw a twenty-one at the blackjack table.
The casino analogy is an accurate one. If the casino gambler draws several blackjacks in a row, he is tempted to believe this wealth “creation” is the natural order of the universe—especially if “validated” by a Wall Street quant or other learned dunderhead. Should his lucky streak continue, he may no longer consider it mere chance but the result of his own previously unrealized talents, and he’ll keep his chips on the table rather than lose out on what seems like easy money. He’ll tell his family and friends who will show up with their own chips (and increasingly with borrowed ones) and try to duplicate his results. If by chance, they’re initially successful, word will spread, and other family and friends, strangers, too, arrive to feast on guaranteed riches—and I assure you that people, including so-called experts, will wholeheartedly believe an endless streak of blackjacks is an inviolate law of the universe; in fact, mathematical proof of this amazing state of affairs will appear in august economics journals. And while an individual or two may have enough sense (or luck) to cash out with some profits, in the aggregate there will be huge losses, not the least of which is the societal wealth that was lost because people were at the casino rather than engaged in more-productive endeavors.
For several years the housing market was a giant casino. There might as well have been scantily-clad cocktail waitresses passing out free drinks—well, perhaps there were at realtor conventions and mortgage broker retreats. The blackjacks kept coming as they’d never come before. Indeed, stupidity and greed were handsomely rewarded—for a while.
All because the housing market was far removed from a truly private-sector free-market. Due to artificial pressures earnestly applied by politicians (to get our votes, obviously), the real estate market has been out of whack for quite some time. The government has long interfered in the real estate market, taking the side of the homeowner over the renter, almost to the point of open contempt toward the latter.
Real estate has been subsidized socialistically through mortgage interest tax deductions, capital gains exclusions, FHA and VA lending, the implicit government backing of mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (and directing these and other institutions to lend to poor minorities), and the Federal Reserve Bank keeping interest rates artificially low.
The reckless printing of money (“quantitative easing” is the Orwellian term for this) is a firetruck of kerosene dispatched to a house fire. A debased currency requires somewhere for the excess dollars to go, and real estate (and the stock market) is often a landing spot for this Monopoly money. That these dollars are disproportionately in the hands of our betters, who profit even after taking the inevitable inflation into account, is further proof of the privileged socialism enjoyed by Wall Street.
Housing prices reflected this meddling—they are much higher than they would otherwise be if these socialistic policies were not in place. And a significantly larger percentage of our national resources are directed at building, selling, appraising, mortgaging, second mortgaging, and upgrading homes than perhaps would occur under truly free-market conditions. We might as well add in the foreclosing gerund, too, while were at it, since a lot more resources than normal ended up going toward this unseemly activity than would’ve been necessary had the housing sector not been artificially overheated. A perverse Soviet-style, centrally-planned sector of the economy lorded over by realtors and mortgage-bundlers rather than commissars.
The housing sector of our economy is horribly distorted by government meddling. Like a cliché balloon filled up with air far beyond the bursting point.
And we’re always astonished when it pops.
Go figure.
I seem to recall several prominent economist folks telling us that a bubble can’t be recognized until after it bursts. I don’t know about you, but it was obvious to me there was a housing bubble getting bigger and bigger, heading to an inevitable explosion—and I’m no economic maestro.
The people want delusion rather than reality.
The government deludes the unthinking public into thinking it’s helping us buy homes. This is a con job to get our votes. Housing prices would be much lower—and the future tax increases necessary to pay for these subsidies (which as part of the federal deficit have been funded partly by borrowed money) would be avoided. We are ultimately paying far more for these subsidies than we are actually receiving. It’s all part of a huge political scam; the fiscal equivalent of bread and circuses to keep the masses happy. Bliss. Ignorant bliss. Heavy on the ignorant. We are too stupid to realize that we are paying dearly for our own bread and circuses—and the fun we derive at first is not going to come close to making up for the later misery we’re due.
The whole system was ginned to promote a farcical public policy that homeownership was desirable and that renting was not. A housing house of cards. The bailout was intended to keep the cards in place despite the increasingly strong winds battering the flimsy creation.
Our financial overlords had to be saved at any cost—and the cost would be huge.
Lies and stupidity and greed absent a free-market piper to reimburse is socialism. As it turns out, what we thought was capitalism was, in fact, socialism in disguise. A perverted form of socialism that says a nanny state can provide us lots of stuff without taxing for it; borrowing money—and making unfunded promises of future spending—allowed us to pretend we were disciples of Adam Smith rather than adherents of Karl Marx. We came to believe we were entitled to the utopian world promised by Comrade Marx at no more cost than one based on Grover Norquist’s tax-cuts-at-all-cost principles.
We’ve been damn dumb with little sign of smartening up anytime soon.
But there’s more.
Add to an abandonment of capitalism and the sense of entitlement, a belief that consequences could be deferred to some fantasy future where all would be set right; or if not sufficiently delayed in time could at least get foisted onto someone else. The proverbial future poor bastard who so has his shit together than he can deal with his own problems and solve all the ones we’ve been stockpiling for decades. He’ll pay his own taxes and the taxes we deferred to a later date as a result of our borrowing money to increase current spending and cut current taxes.
We must stop at this point for an economic truth: A politician who increases spending or cuts taxes, either of which is wholly or partly funded by deficit spending, is a tax increaser—in the future. Such actions are the economic equivalent of using a time machine to transport oneself to the future in order to vote for a tax increase. Democrats and Republicans are both guilty of this fiscal sleight-of-hand…they are Morlocks who feast today on tomorrow’s unborn Eloi.
Not that the champions of the private sector were any less guilty. Everyone borrowed up a storm, a veritable maelstrom of IOUs. Corporations and individuals alike. Snug in the eye of the hurricane, we could not imagine the sunny skies any color but a blinding azure, we could not imagine the destructive winds veering our way. To rephrase one of my favorite aphorisms: The future is a foreign country; they do things differently there.
Cruder still. Shitting in one’s nest is ill-advised; pooping in someone else’s isn’t such a big deal; crapping in a future nest that isn’t one’s own is best of all. Yes, there was the belief that a failure of these bundled “investments” (and there were voices who warned of this inevitability in the years leading up to this boondoggle) would end up someone else’s problem—
The original borrower who might’ve lied on his application or been duped by a slick mortgage broker; the Wall Street firm who took leverage to irresponsible heights of folly; the ratings company which swore this swill was a delicious securitized stew; the “insurer” who’d laughably make good on any losses; the end investor (e.g., pension fund, foreign government) whose own experts should’ve known better than to purchase these crappy investments; or at the very least the government who’d ride in like a knight on shining armor (albeit heavily-mortgaged armor) and save us all from folly completely of our own making.
With every person at every stage in the process so eager and reckless and willing and delusional, how could a boondoggle not come to be? If ever any disastrous financial event was destined to come to pass, the Great Recession was it. There are no innocents in this matter. We all had it coming.
As false as it obviously was, everyone involved held dearly a basic belief underlying this scheme: Somehow continuing deterioration in housing affordability (what everyone so glibly calls “appreciation”) would enable the scheme to be pulled off without there ever dawning a day of reckoning.
Any idiot could see this wasn’t true. A reckoning will always have its day. Housing prices were far outstripping average income levels. An unsustainable housing bubble was obviously in the works. An important fact was ignored by everyone from the homebuyer to the end investor in a far-off land buying his mortgage: Housing inflation (appreciation) does not correlate to the underlying ability of a borrower to pay off a monthly mortgage; nor is housing inflation, or the increase in cost of any other necessity of life, desirable public policy.
True economic progress generally results in lower prices. This benefits society and increases wealth. In the 1800s a family traveling from the East to a new life Out West paid a huge monetary price—if not with actual lives lost—and endured tremendous physical hardship in order to make the trip. Today a move or a vacation which requires the same distance traveled is affordable to most people, and presents nowhere near the same challenges, and it can be done in a fraction of the time. Fortunately, there wasn’t a public policy at the time of the earlier settlers that the cost of such trips must be kept artificially high to protect the interests of wagon makers, horse breeders, provisioners, and scouts. (Though I wonder if there’s a tax break for horse farms snuck somewhere in today’s tax code.)
It wasn’t that long ago when only the wealthy could purchase and eat fresh fruits or vegetables out of season or outside of areas where these crops were grown. Now we take for granted these items are available in our grocery stores year-round at a reasonable cost. These are just a few examples of the benefits of progress. True economic advancement.
Politicians want higher housing prices, which means they want homes to be as unaffordable as possible. Time and time again during this crisis a pundit or politician spouted off that the decline in housing prices was the problem and was making it difficult for borrowers to pay their home mortgages or make payments on the “equity” loans they’d stupidly extracted from their abodes. The implied public policy was that the bubble must be kept inflated to save the foolish homeowners and lenders, though of course the real message was that pathetic efforts to blow air into a shredded balloon were being done to save all of us, not just the financially foolish.
This is ignorant bullshit. As far as reliably making a loan payment, the person’s monthly income is what matters. The only thing that matters. The only thing that will ever matter. This is true whether the borrower is an individual homeowner or a gigantic corporation or a government. Had this one simple fact not been ignored by borrowers, lenders, underwriters, securitizers, investors, raters, bond insurers, or regulators (only one of these groups needed to have realized it to have saved us from ourselves), there would’ve been no financial crisis in 2007-2009.
So simple; and yet it was beyond the comprehension of the many simpletons masquerading as financial gurus and political leaders.
Be First to Comment